Jump to content

How important is originality in materials?


6219_Rules

Recommended Posts

Here is a topic that may have been bandied about before but I thought I would raise it again since I was not privy to the outcome of the previous discussion.

How important is it to maintain originality in the materials one uses for the interior of a collector car?

Is it a question of originality for show? Or a question of being a selling point should you want the top dollar for you car? At what point is the owners comfort and ability to afford a makeover no longer primary? Or does it really not matter?

Please I hope to see some discussion on this! I have a reason for asking <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" /> <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/laugh.gif" alt="" />

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Chuck Conrad

It costs nearly the same amount of money to restore a car?s interior using the proper materials as it does to re-do it using the wrong stuff. If the interior has proper workmanship, then the labor is the really big-ticket item. When you go to sell the car, unless it is a street rod (in that case, all bets are off?) then the authentic interior is going to make it more desirable to the collector.

Of course, you can just do a cheap job, using non-authentic materials and techniques. That will be less expensive labor wise, but you are doing nothing towards preserving automotive history.

It?s your car though, so it?s your choice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I "second" Chuck's remarks....with the following additional comments. Think about why we mess with these old "pains-in-the-hindquarters" in the first place. How did the Classic Car Club get established....what did we want to do....how is that reflected in our judging, and how does this differ from the "public car show" events.

Take painting, for example. Proper preparation of the surface is 90% of the cost and effort. Of COURSE the modern "two part" (heck..even the "one part") paints are vastly superior to the nitrocellulose lacquer used up thru roughly mid 1955, when acrylic lacquer and other "magic chemicals" started appearing). Superior in durability, and in "shine".

My personal prejudice is that even the un-trained eye can spot the difference in the way they "look" - a function of the way light reacts off the different chemical structure. Nitrocellulose lacquer and its "accessory" chemicals are still available - even in California you can still buy thinner, so getting it is not a problem.

The problem is...what are you going to DO with that "collector car" once you get it fixed up. If you want to compete in the PUBLIC car shows, where the event is centered around pleasing the spectator, who may have paid a LOT of money to get in and thus has a right to be "entertained", then I would recommend going to the modern "showy" paint materials and schemes. As for CCCA events, it was only relatively recently that we do NOT take off for the "wrong" paint - even so, you WILL get "raised noses" from us "old timers" for the use of non-original finishes.

As Chuck notes, forget about using non-original upholstery and/or patterns. The expense isnt that much different. And...he is being gracious...many of us feel this effectively destroys the car. Even the "public show" crowd types will probably spot it and wrinkle their noses.

I personally cringe at over-chroming, especially on cars that were built before the chrome era. But again...what are your personal needs...where are you going to take your car. Public car show ? Want to win prizes. In that case..go ahead and chrome the hell out of it....!

Again, bottom line...think back about why we have a CCCA in the first place. To encourage PERSERVATION of these fine old "engineering exaggerations...magnificently over-done" as they were when new cars. A review of CCCA judging rules, confirm we still pretty much follow our original intent, which was to encourage RESTORATION to what they were when new.

Our judging is based on an OBJECTIVE view of how closely the car was returned to the condition it was on delivery day to the first owner. A car being delivered to its first owner was NOT "jewelery case perfect". It had GREASE on its grease fittings...maybe some road dust or "splash" from being road-tested. Of COURSE that will get you sneers of disapproval at these fancy PUBLIC car shows.

But...each to his own. BEST thing for you to do...is...do what is good for YOU. It IS your car...! Be assured that no matter WHAT you do...there is always some wise-guy who will find fault with it. So what...as Chuck has implied...this is NOT a religion..it IS a hobby !

PFH

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you, PFH. I appreciate your well thoughtout, concise and polite replies. It is a great pleasure having a resource like you and the others at my finger tips. I would like to have the opportunity one day of sitting down to a cold beer and some good conversation about Packards, and other cars. <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" />

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chuck, et al, I must beg your pardon. I have done a terrible thing through ignorance.

When I had the '47 redone on the interior, I chose a non-original cotton batting (Poly blend) in dove grey with dark blue piping to match the dark blue exterior (which was to be painted later...the last owner painted the car in a bright blue rather than the original dark blue). I did this more because I was told it would wear better and feel better. It does look good but now I see I have spoiled the car.

When I had the clock and radio redone, I had them reworked with digital workings. The radio still sports a single large speaker but will get AM/FM and takes a modern CD or MP3 player through a hidden jack underneath. Another faux pas.

I have been reading the CCCA Judging sections and now wonder if the interior door handles, window cranks and the like should be chrome, stainless steel or nickel. Does anyone know for sure? Damn being a novice can sure be expensive and embarrassing. <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/blush.gif" alt="" />

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The only stainless steel on door handles I am aware (there may be a few others) for regular production American cars are the EXTERIOR door handles on the '38 Packard Twelve and Super Eight. SOME luxury cars of the 1930's were still using nickel for SOME interior plating - as is the case on "big" Packards - EVERY fitting on the interior of my '38 Formal Sedan, from the rim frames on the mirrors of the vanity cases, to the door handles, was nickel - only the dash "pot metal" parts were chromed.

Obviously, chrome is much more durable and practical - to my knowledge, nickel did not appear on production cars, even the luxury ones such as the Packard and Caddy limos, after World War Two. For your '47, you want chrome. Finding a reliable chrome shop that wont

1) lose your parts

2) grind and buff what they DONT lose into smoothed-over junk....

is a whole separate problem !

PFH

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tell me about it. IT looks as though the previous owner took a rouge wheel to several door handles and buffed them, uh, smooth. I don't think they are too damaged but I would have prefered had he done nothing instead.

So chrome is the way to go. OK. I was reading in the CCCA and AACA forums getting more worried as I went. I hate to think I did more damage than good to this venerable old beauty.

Probably would be best were I to sell it to someone who can afford and has the experience to restore it right. I am learning but I am not doing it very well.

Thanks, PHF. You are, as usual, informative and a gentleman.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Chuck Conrad

I'm not sure you've "done a terrible thing," you just made the car the way you wanted it to be. That's not the end of the world, but as you've noticed, it does very little to preserve the history of the car.

You can still have fun with it, take it on CARavans and tours and do all the other stuff we enjoy doing with our cars. Just don't be too surprised when you enter it into AACA, Cad-LaSalle or CCCA judging events that it doesn't score as well as you might like.

As PH points out, at local shows, the judges there may really like what you've done with it and bestow ribbons and trophies on it. You never know.

Don't feel bad, in my earlier car collecting days, I did many of the same things you are doing, simply because I didn't know any better. I still enjoyed the cars though...

Gee, I wonder where that 1952 Mercedes withe the plaid seats is now? It was really "sharp" in 1975.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Awini

as far as original materials go,i have a problem. My 1939 lagonda was imported into India in 1940 by the Maharajah of Jodhpur, as he drove this car himself,he had the seat reupholstered in Tiger skin, from the tigers he shot.sometime in the sixties the car was upholstered in red and black rexine as the skin had perished. the car still has this upholstery. where am i to get tiger skins now?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tiger skins.....

This is no joke - as many of you know, "Ziegie" and Roy have for many years had an extremely successful (as in "pricey") magic act in Las Vegas (last I heard it was up around a hundred bucks a ticket..and their shows are usually sold out days in advance ).

Anyway, they have done quite well for themselves, amassing collections of all sorts of valuables, including "collector" cars.

You can see where this is going....? This is for REAL...some years ago, a not too bright burglar broke into their estate, winding up in one of their garages, which is attached to the main house. Oh, yes, as many of you know, Zieg and Roy have reaised their tigers from cubs, and treat them as house-pets. NOW you see where this is going...can you see the expression on the burglar's face when he confronts one of the "pet kitties"....? He found a phone, called the police and BEGGED them to get him out of there and arrest him....!

Fortunately for the "not-too-swift" burglar, about the only thing dumber around that estate that night...was the "nice kittie".......these animals apparently make lousy watch-dogs...they just wanted to play with him. ....

By the time he got to the phone, he'd triggered several silent alarms, so he was quickly "rescued" into the arms of justice. Damn...that must have been a funny scene...can't you see it...? " Nice...kittie...NICE kittle...."

PFH

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What a handsome car you have there, Sir. I would put my two Rupies in and suggest one of two options. First, research the original manufacturers specifications for the materials or better yet do an online search based on your car. I think there are people that do that, nez pas?

Or secondly you could restore the car to the condition that the Rajput had envisioned. There is absolutely no reason why a Tiger has to die for it. There are man made materials, some of them museum grade that while expensive would give the look and feel of the Tiger pelt without the illegal destruction of so magnificent a beast. Yes boys and girls, I am not only a vile liberal bent on the total destruction of every value held by the good and true, but also an environmentalist!

ACK. Satan's Little Helper.

Anyway, Awini, I think your car is magnificent and I would love to see more pictures of it posted on the Photo forum. Can you tell us a little more about it?

Yours sincerely in the Heart of the American Bush.....SLH

Link to comment
Share on other sites

<img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/blush.gif" alt="" /> <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/blush.gif" alt="" /> <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/blush.gif" alt="" /> Delete it quick, Restorer, before the liberals find you out! Wayne

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great Discussion Awini! Rarely have so many wonderful topics and issues that confront our hobby been contained in one thread! Luckily Awini doenst have to import the hides. If we start promoting smuggling here the feds will be onto us for sure. LOL

what say you, Awini, do you think it is possible to get a real pelt? I mean tigers die like everyone else eventually. Whats politically incorrect about using hides from tigers that died of natural causes. What's the lifespan of a tiger anyway? Questions, questions

Shawn

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Awini

it is possible to get skins but its not worth getting arrested for.besides i am fanatically against poaching, we have so few tigers left,i have seen them in the wild and they are a magnificiant beast.legal skins rarely change hands and are constanty tracked by the government, and owners cant alter them.

according to the lagonda club, this car war built for the company president, Alan Good and he used it for a short while.this car is just six chassis after the two Le Mans V12 Racers.it has a hybred engine and a higher ratio rear axle from the medium wheelbase chassis,as Lagonda could not supply a car in the midst of WWII, this car was refurbished For the Maharajah of Jodhpur and left the factory for India in Sep 1940, im glad it reached India at all, as so many ships were sunk those days.it left the factory with brown seats,tan top and burgundy body, so i guess thats what its going to be some day. for now i will keep it as is. the shabbyest V12 rapide on earth <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" />who knows, WO might have worked on this car himself....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting...so they track the ownership of hides, huh...and you cant alter them by like cutting them to fit properly. Oh well, the original leather probably will look better anyway. What a great car to have!

The only reason i was intrigued about the possibility of getting real skins would be that the history of the car is so interesting and unique.

So how did you come to own this beauty? It wasnt listed in the paper or anything was it?

Shawn

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Awini

i have known this car for years, and in fact it was actually advertised in a magazine classified in 1999. but didnt sell, i got it as a wedding gift from my dad in nov 2000, it wasnt running then because of a broken timing gear,thats why it didnt sell,all the big collecters vere scared, no one thought of contacting a specialist to find out what could be wrong.which i did, and ended up with a car i could not have dreamed of owning otherwise. dad paid about $50,000 for it, which has to be the bargain of the new millenium. i actually had a choice between a new mercedes and this car, i chose the Lagonda. i have the greatest dad in the world

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great story! Excellent choice as well, that "new" Mercedes would be worth about half what it cost new by now.

Great deals are out there, especially when the car has some "issues". I guy in my area bought a pretty nice 47 caddy convertible for around 20 because it wouldnt run well, and later discovered that the distributor wires were crossed.

I got the daVinci basically because no one else wanted it, what with the motor being in pieces and the body chopped up and all (maybe everyone else was right) HA!

Shawn

Link to comment
Share on other sites

there is a page devoted to it on my website

www.4stargallery.com/mycaraddiction

Progress is eaking ever forward on this car and I am in the process of getting it declared a full classic. the chassis goes off to the blasting shop this week, and then it will be painted, and then we can start reassembling it! The plan is to go with a running driving bare show chassis for the first year, while continuing to work on the body, which i have decided will be the convertible sedan it was before the rear half was chopped off in the 50's. Part of me wants to keep going and build all 5 of the bodies booth designed and then be able to switch them around but a big part of me wants to just be done and move onto my other project cars sometime before I keel over.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We do have a few classic automobiles here on the shores of the swamps in eastern Latvia....like most classics, they were upholstered in the finest fabrics of that day - Laidlaw Broadcloth. Mohair was typically found in the less expensive cars.

Here in Latvia, when we can't hunt reindeer (damn bunny-huggin ecology freaks spy on us...) we hunt the Great Latvian Nauga. We sneak up on em, using our special "nauga-caller". It has a peculiar raspy sound...some compare it to a mother-in-law.......

When we lure a Great Latvian Nauga in close enough.....we put salt on their tails...that confuses them, and while they are confused, we tear their heads off...skin em...eat the insides, and then sell the pelts to Detroit - so...now you know where naugha-hide comes from.....

PFH...( Perfidious..etc...etc...)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dear PH,Just developed a new product you might be interested in,tanning booth large enough for even your biggest Nauga.You know so you don't have to dye the hides,just spray with PAM and turn em once in a while,if a color is desired we just use the spray bomb.Works in Buffalo,90 today,think it might SNOW by Sunday.diz <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/blush.gif" alt="" /> <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/blush.gif" alt="" /> <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/blush.gif" alt="" /> <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/blush.gif" alt="" /> <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/blush.gif" alt="" />

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Impressive website, Shawn! I can see why you are a forum moderator!

Did I tell you the '47 Caddy had to go to the shop yesterday? I was driving it in to have the right rear spring un-popped (the Goodyear mechanic rotated my tires using a jack...ah me) and the silly thing stopped running. So I sat in the warm sun shine and enjoyed my car as I awaited the flatbed. I was pretty sure what the problem was. Since the rear end us up in the right side, and the car ran flawlessly for ten minutes or more, I figured it was something in the gas tank that would float to the intake pipe and pug it. Sure enough, the tank was removed and there it was...stuff floating in the gas. Apparently the tank had been sealed but for some reason there is a lot of junk in it floating free. So for the happy sum of $600.00 I am having the tank re-cleaned, the lines cleared and hopefully the car back in several weeks, because unlike so many I know, my income is in direct proportion to my car's needs. I already had to borrow to have the Old's radiator replaced two days ago! SURPRISE! I love old cars. <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" /> Wouldn't change it for a new Ford Focus on a bet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks, but actually the website needs updating, woefully.

Sorry to hear about your tank problems. Feul system problems are the most common collector car problems these days with the new gas and all. If you have an electric fuel pump installed and it is more than 2 years old I would replace it. the new gas eats through the rubber bladder material, same for hoses and rubber gas lines. these all need replaced it they are more than a couple of years old thanks to the gubment screwing with the gas formulas.

BTW don't try to syphon the new gas by sucking on the end of the line. it tastes terrible! HA

Shawn

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You're right there, Shawn. I both have an electric inline pump, and I have tried to syphon gas...yecckk! I should look into replacing that pump so I will start looking online for a new one.

The gas tank problem is weird. But its no big deal other than the cost. That hoits!! Anyway I have AAA so I was OK. At least I could be taken home after I had the car towed in. I can hardly wait to get it back. <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" />

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Chuck Conrad

Not only does modern gas taste terrible, it is potentially VERY harmful to you. Don't ever injest it. MBTE is added to it in some areas, and it is reportedly a carcinogen. Even a few drops of some modern gasoline can cause you big problems.

If you get this stuff on your skin and consume alcohol shortly thereafter, you will find that your alcohol tolerance is very low. It?s an interesting side effect, that can?t be very good for you. If the winos ever figure this out, siphoning your tank, and finishing it off with a bottle of MD 20/20 will become the next fad.

<img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/shocked.gif" alt="" />

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yikes! I only did it once and got a little on my lips...I washed it immediately. I don't drink <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" />

Seriously though, I haven't syphoned in 20 years.

Anyway the Caddy is set so now I can pay the bill. I have asked for aid on several projects particularly my son's 72 Eldorado's transmission needing servicing and I have received so much good advice it is simply amazing. I cannot thank you people enough. It is a real pleasure.

I hope to meet some of you some day. If you are ever in the Denver area, drop me a line!

You will always be welcome in Erie. <img src="http://www.aaca.org/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/laugh.gif" alt="" />

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...