Nolan Walker

Is it better to buy a used car compared to a new car?

Recommended Posts


Hello Guys,
I am from New jersey and I would like to know your opinions about buy a used car compared to a new car, which one is best option.So please suggest me. I read a couple of blogs on used, so just checking on it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


Benefits of AACA Membership.

Posted (edited)

New cars are not cheap.. Here is one for 75K --- sale tax and the other stuff??

kai.jpg

IMG_6325[26265].jpg

carsss.jpg

Edited by nick8086 (see edit history)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Consider buying a used car, but buy a good one,

maybe 2 to 4 years old.  You can save half the original

price, then use the money you save to invest properly.

You can also buy a better car, a more expensive

model than you could otherwise afford.

 

Many modern cars don't excite the buyer anymore.

Most are utility vehicles and 4-door sedans, and

the color selection is atrocious.  Do you like black,

white, and shades of gray?  Do the designers realize

the vast color range that truly exists?

 

I always check Consumer Reports, and the used cars

I have bought have had "Much Better than Average"

reliability, their best ranking.  I have not been disappointed.

Edited by John_S_in_Penna (see edit history)
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dittos.  Let someone else eat the initial depreciation.  Just be careful and try to avoid factory buy-backs.  Those were lemons that dealerships couldn't fix. Let your fingers do the walking.  There is a lot of info out there on the internet about what to watch for. 

Terry

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My last car was a Certified Used car. To me that is a great way to go. Mine was just under a year old with about 20,000 miles on it and came with a great warranty. Way less money than a new one and checked out and approved by the manufacturer.  Only one issue with it and it was resolved quickly under warranty. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are many discounts available to new car purchases and financing can be lower for new vs used.  Big factor is how long you keep it.  If you keep the new car for 10 years the difference in price is decreased.  When cars had worse reliability than today, I liked  being the first owner so I knew the maintenance history.  Certified pre owned is a relatively new option. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 I am currently looking to purchase a 1932 Ford roadster.

 I would prefer to buy a new one for $460 list price but I may have to get a used one, if I can't get a good deal on a new one.

🙄

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

You need to add additional information.  Type of vehicle; sedan, SUV, convertible, van, etc, price to pay including all warranty cost, how many miles driven per year, max miles on vehicle when you sell it.  
A certified vehicle is actually a better warranty on a used car from a new car dealer.  
One son in law uses a national company called CARMAX to buy 2 year old cars having a warranty.  They are higher priced than a dealer used car lot but their price is not negotiable.  He usually trades at 160,000 miles. 

A 2nd son in law buys near new cars but about 6 years ago he bought a Toyota SUV with 60,000 miles but it now had 230,000 miles.

I like lower mile vehicles and replaced my 2006 truck with 61,000 miles with a 9,200 mile 2015 Dodge.  The Dodge is used to tow a trailer & not my primary vehicle, Without a warranty. I am gambling I can afford the repair bills.  

 

Clark Howard suggests you purchase a newer used car & drive it 10 years.  Check Consumer Reports at your library as a good reference for dependability.

Edited by huptoy (see edit history)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It depends on cars. You can't say for sure. In different cases different ways.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't really think there's any such thing as a bad car being built these days. A two-year-old car coming off lease with, say, 25,000 miles on it is usually available for half price. I've bought my last three cars that way and ended up with way more car than I could otherwise justify. Both of those cars lasted well over 100,000 miles and I'm still driving the most recent one. I think it's a no-brainer to let someone else take the hit and pick up the car after it has finished with the steep part of the depreciation curve. Most cars are driven pretty sedately and not abused, maintenance has pretty much become "put gas in it when the needle gets close to E," and quality is pretty uniformly high--even Kias are pretty decent cars these days and just about anything you buy should give you 100,000 trouble-free miles.

 

My only caveat might be if you're aiming for a high-end European car--buying one of those is a bit of a gamble. I won with one but if I were to buy another European car with a warranty that was going to expire, I might pony up for an aftermarket warranty. Yes, you'll spend $3000-4000 on the warranty, but when a transmission is $9000 and a set of turbos is $12,000, it might be a smart gamble.

 

There's also the lease option. Some people object to leasing because they don't have a car when it's over, but if you think of it as a fixed payment and you will always have a new car with a warranty, it kind of balances out. It's a mistake to treat a car as an appreciating asset, old or new, so simply making a payment to use one and every few years you get a new one can be a good way to go if you don't want to risk not having a warranty or service coverage.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Hertz is probably going bankrupt in the next 60 days........(90 percent chance?)....that puts 360,000 cars into the used car market....mostly newer and low milage. The used car market is going to take a dump like it has NEVER seen. Remember modern newer cars depreciate very, very fast. They will have to fire sale them as fast as humanly possible. Save your money now.....have CASH in a checking account ready to go.............your going to get some insane values very soon.......and Hertz has mostly high end models with all the toys............I expect to purchase two cars from them soon......Ed

 

 

Then add in all the other rentals that will also get dumped............from all the other national chains.........its going to be a blood bath.........bad news if you purchased a car in the last 18 months...........good news if you going to be in the market soon.

 

 

Edited by edinmass (see edit history)
  • Like 3
  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
33 minutes ago, edinmass said:

Hertz is probably going bankrupt in the next 60 days........(90 percent chance?)....that puts 360,000 cars into the used car market....mostly newer and low milage. The used car market is going to take a dump like it has NEVER seen. Remember modern newer cars depreciate very, very fast. They will have to fire sale them as fast as humanly possible. Save your money now.....have CASH in a checking account ready to go.............your going to get some insane values very soon.......and Hertz has mostly high end models with all the toys............I expect to purchase two cars from them soon......Ed

 

 

Then add in all the other rentals that will also get dumped............from all the other national chains.........its going to be a blood bath.........bad news if you purchased a car in the last 18 months...........good news if you going to be in the market soon.

 

 

Since they most likely will all go to auction, boy that will be one hell of an auction to be at.  After the first few go through they'll just about be giving them away to get rid of them. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 minutes ago, auburnseeker said:

Since they most likely will all go to auction, boy that will be one hell of an auction to be at.  After the first few go through they'll just about be giving them away to get rid of them. 

 

They'll probably send them to Mannheim or Adesa to wholesale to dealers, and it'll still be regional so all the cars won't be dumped in one place for one auction. In fact, I just mentioned to Melanie last week that we should start paying attention to our Mannheim inventory alerts because of Hertz going belly-up. A new tow vehicle or a replacement for my Cadillac CTS wagon for a discounted wholesale price? Nice.

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Matt Harwood said:

 

They'll probably send them to Mannheim or Adesa to wholesale to dealers, and it'll still be regional so all the cars won't be dumped in one place for one auction. In fact, I just mentioned to Melanie last week that we should start paying attention to our Mannheim inventory alerts because of Hertz going belly-up. A new tow vehicle or a replacement for my Cadillac CTS wagon for a discounted wholesale price? Nice.

I went to an auction in Florida with a dealer that i got hooked up with to buy a new (used) work truck.  You don't buy used trucks in the Northeast.  A 4 year old HD 2500 Series gas Chevy 4x4 went through with a contractors cap big winch front bumper in nice shape other than a dent on the box side with just about 100K and absolutely no rust.  Almost got it for 4G until some other guy jumped on and ran it to 6G then bailed.  I did put a tranny in it about 40K later but also another 120k on it total and finally sold it for 2G after having it 10 years.  Can't complain about that one.  Of course the dealer knew which lanes to go to and which to avoid.  Helps to have the right guy. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I used to by good, low mileage used cars all the time, especially for the reasons stated above. All less than 20,000 miles. My opinion is changing though. I am a volunteer fireman and most of our calls are accident calls. The newer cars have far superior crumple zones and you can't imagine the amount of damage and still people walk away. Now, when you consider the average hourly charge for good mechanics is approaching $150 per hour, you better have a warrantee. Most cars over 35,000 miles and you're on your own. If I'm buying a used car, it will have less than 20,000 miles or I look elsewhere.

 

Frank

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
6 hours ago, Nolan Walker said:


Hello Guys,
I am from New jersey and I would like to know your opinions about buy a used car compared to a new car, which one is best option.So please suggest me. I read a couple of blogs on used, so just checking on it.

Well, it really depends on a lot of variables, including what type of car/vehicle are you needing/wanting ? What type of driving/usage you expect from it ? Is it for a single person or family ? Your budget ($20K or $85K) ?  Are you able to pay cash or will it need to be financed ? Etc, etc, etc, ...

These are some of the basics you need to figure out and present to others before any practical advise can (or should) be offered.

 

OTOH, if you're just looking for "opinions" (and you know, everybody has at least one) by others, based on their personal desires and/or experiences, you can ignore my above suggestions. 

Edited by TTR (see edit history)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am 83 and have NEVER had a new car.  Mostly low mileage 10 year or older. Insurance savings alone are immense. But then I have never used one for work.  

 I owned and drove a semi truck for 40 years. After 3 new ones, the rest were used.  I drove one for 11 years. I agree with Matt, few if any cares today are bad and few if any that will not go 150,000 or 200,000 miles.

 Of course, if one has the money, spend the darn stuff. The economy needs for us to do so.

 

  Ben

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are some pretty great deals out there now too.  My last car was a 2 year old Lincoln MKX CPO. As stated above , the certified warranty is better than the new car warranty.  It’s been a relatively trouble free car for the 5 years I’ve had it.  It was a rental return.  I have purchased many rental returns over the years and have never been disappointed. 

 

Today I am picking up a 2019 Challenger R/T as a CPO car. I was very particular in what I wanted so I was pleased to find almost exactly what I wanted and in a color I liked. I also got an insane deal on the price. This car has 22K miles and as I drive less than 3K miles a year for this car, it will probably be my last car. (I’ve said that about my last 3 cars though)

 

I looked at new ones but the dealers weren’t willing to discount much below MSRP - rebates so I walked. There was one other CPO car that had about half the miles this one had and their asking price was just a little higher than the one I bought.  The show stoppers were The color, white, and they weren’t too generous with my trade.  I usually sell my trades outright but with the virus and all i decided to take the easy way out. I’d advocate for a CPO used car any day.  Let someone else take the depreciation hit.

 

Interesting, I hadn’t heard about Hertz. I worked for them for a short while as a part time retirement job.  Too bad if they are folding.  I met some great people working there.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Although this may or may not be relevant the last time we bought a car it was for my wife. She wanted a Kia Soul and when I began checking prices on used ones(also my preferred choice) I came to realize that the cost difference between a quality used one and a new one was about $1000 or so. Adding in the extremely low cost financing and excellent warranty on a new Kia it was silly to buy used.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, huptoy said:

You need to add additional information.  Type of vehicle; sedan, SUV, convertible, van, etc, price to pay including all warranty cost, how many miles driven per year, max miles on vehicle when you sell it.  
A certified vehicle is actually a better warranty on a used car from a new car dealer.  
One son in law uses a national company called CARMAX to buy 2 year old cars having a warranty.  They are higher priced than a dealer used car lot but their price is not negotiable.  He usually trades at 160,000 miles. 

A 2nd son in law buys near new cars but about 6 years ago he bought a Toyota SUV with 60,000 miles but it now had 230,000 miles.

I like lower mile vehicles and replaced my 2006 truck with 61,000 miles with a 9,200 mile 2015 Dodge.  The Dodge is used to tow a trailer & not my primary vehicle, Without a warranty. I am gambling I can afford the repair bills.  

 

Clark Howard suggests you purchase a newer used car & drive it 10 years.  Check Consumer Reports at your library as a good reference for dependability.

 

I bought a four year old 2014 Chevy Equinox from Carmax that had only 14,000 miles on it. It was like new at half the cost of a brand new one. Found out that the way CARMAX works is they get used vehicles from the larger Auto Auctions and when you trade a car in at Carmax an Appraiser from the auction comes to Carmax to buy it from Carmax and auctions it off. The trade in cars go to auction. So the CARMAX cars are shipped from the Auction lot for Carmax to sell and your traded in goes to auction. Many of the Corporate Companies that give their sales employees new rental cars to drive and rotate them every 4 years. The employees get new model cars every four years. The company cars are well maintained and low mileage.This gives you great value to purchase this way and CARMAX will not negotiate pricing. We love are Chevy Equinox.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

I have been buying low mileage ten year old cars for 25 years. I also purchased five new one ton dualy Desiel’s five years in a row, trading them in with about 3500 miles on them. I see both sides of the issue. When the market dumps......it’s going to be insane......think like oil the last three months...........with high unemployment, net worth down across the boards, low cash balances for most working Americans.......the new and used car market is going to leave blood in the streets. Hertz won’t be the only large company dumping cars............I think the price will drop to about 30 percent of new delivery cost on most of the inventory for 9 months or more. Remember most of the rental cars are loaded with all the toys......so the plain Jane cars are going to be in the toilet. My current three every day drivers.....97 Chevy S-10 With 103k, 06 Mercedes CLK430 Convertible with 41k, and my 05 Ford Focus with 80k................will probably become of so little value that I will give them to some local people who have fallen on hard times. I will replace all three with 2018 or newer units.......and it will probably only cost me the price of one decent used car from three months ago. I hate to pay insurance on newer cars, so I probably won’t get comprehensive or collision.

Edited by edinmass (see edit history)
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My son traded his car, a 2008 Dodge Caliber that used to be mine, on a 2016 car he bought from carmax.  His Dodge was not sent to auction, it wound up back on the carmax website.  Carmax gave him $2500 for it, they listed it for $8595.  They did put new tires on the front and maybe an alignment.  We checked the vin and the car ownership report they posted.  No question it was his car.  Not saying this is typical but it was our experience with them.  Son has been pleased with his carmax purchase so far.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Matt Harwood said:

just about anything you buy should give you 100,000 trouble-free miles

Aren't you the same guy that had an issue with his tailgate and was forced to go ballistic on the Cadillac customer service girl?:P

 

1 hour ago, oldford said:

Now, when you consider the average hourly charge for good mechanics is approaching $150 per hour, you better have a warrantee

-I just found out that the wife's ford explorer has airbags built into the rear seat belts? This triggered a check engine light and a what should have been a $900 repair had I been outside of the warranty period. I have had an endless smathering of pricey little nuisance problems from our current Ford and Toyota products. New cars are just too complicated-too many gizmos. John Elkann of Fiat Chrysler spoke at Pebble Beach and admitted that modern automobiles now have more lines of code than any Airbus plane. Scary stuff for some poor old stiff like me! 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
8 minutes ago, md murray said:

Aren't you the same guy that had an issue with his tailgate and was forced to go ballistic on the Cadillac customer service girl?:P

 

Correct. And while that incident really pissed me off and damaged my hand (maybe permanently), it didn't stop the car from driving me to work every day. Gas, oil, four wheel bearings, and that goddamned tailgate over the course of 10 years and 130,000 miles. That's probably par for the course for any late-model car these days. I find that acceptable, even though Cadillac and I are currently litigating and I probably won't ever buy another one of their cars.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, plymouthcranbrook said:

Although this may or may not be relevant the last time we bought a car it was for my wife. She wanted a Kia Soul and when I began checking prices on used ones(also my preferred choice) I came to realize that the cost difference between a quality used one and a new one was about $1000 or so. Adding in the extremely low cost financing and excellent warranty on a new Kia it was silly to buy used.

This is true on a few different vehicles.  We did the same for My wife's new Toyota Tacoma. A new one is about 3 grand more than a used one.   Again,  coming from the North Country rust is an issue with used vehicles and very costly repairs. 

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now