What class would this 1925 car be in at an AACA event?

[kfle 235]

I just joined the AACA last year and I have not had a chance to attend one of the shows yet.  I read the car classes and some of the judging documents, but I am a bit confused when it comes to an older unrestored car.  Would this just go in an HPOF class?  I also thought I saw that you could still get a jr or other award in the 400 point class with an original car, but I not sure how that would work if most of the cars are restored.  Thanks for the guidance in advance.

 

Now on to the car.  I acquired this car in January and it is a 1925 Cole Brouette with body by Willoughby.  The car has a lot of history as it was the personal chauffer driven car for Mrs. JJ Cole.  After JJ Cole's death in late 1925, Mrs. Cole used the car until about 1930 and then it was stored in the basement of the Cole factory with some other cars until 1990.  The Cole family maintained the cars while in the basement and took them out on occasion for family events and to drive.  The car was then moved to the Cole mansion in Indianapolis after a relative of the Cole family purchased the house and the car.  Both the house and the Brouette were placed on the National Register of Historic places in 1997.  The national park service inspected the property and the car and documented it as part of the process.  In 2007 the mansion was then sold as well as the car and a private collector purchased it.  I then acquired it from that person in January of this year.  The car is predominately all original exterior and interior and has only had parts replaced that would be expected to be replaced to maintain the car and to keep it running such as hoses, plugs, tires, etc.  The paint is original though has been cosmetically touched up over the years.  The body is aluminum except for the engine cover and that helped with preservation.  We believe that the top material was replaced at some point.  Also, after some engine work in 2008, the previous owner repainted the engine top with the original engine color that was on there.  There are some dings as you would expect, but nothing major.   Here are some pictures and a page from the park service report.  I also scanned an older photograph of the car at the Cole mansion.  

 

 

Edited February 18, 2019 by kfle (see edit history)

[TerryB 1,530]

I have no idea of the AACA class but that is one nice automobile!

[keiser31 4,137]

Probably H.P.O.F.(historical preservation of original features).

[Steve Moskowitz 1,516]

HPOF would be great but if you wanted to compete with restored cars there is nothing to stop you.  Getting a second or third place award in those classes is still an accomplishment.  It looks like this is a four wheel brake car and I believe it is an 8 cylinder which would put it in class 18C if being judged. 

[kfle 235]

3 minutes ago, Steve Moskowitz said:

HPOF would be great but if you wanted to compete with restored cars there is nothing to stop you.  Getting a second or third place award in those classes is still an accomplishment.  It looks like this is a four wheel brake car and I believe it is an 8 cylinder which would put it in class 18C if being judged. 

Steve,

 

Thanks and yes, you are correct.  It is a four wheel brake car and it has a V8.  So is 18C the 400 point judged class?  Is HPOF just one big class?

[Phillip Cole 152]

I looked up the National Register on the property and the car. Considering you have a car with such documented provenance,  you should seriously consider restoring it to be class judged. 

 

[nzcarnerd 582]

If it is mostly original, leave it as it is. It is only original once - you can never unrestore a car.

[Steve Moskowitz 1,516]

Keith you have it correct.  Just remember that there can be multiple winners for either class judging or our evaluated cars (HPOF & DPC). 

[kfle 235]

24 minutes ago, Steve Moskowitz said:

Keith you have it correct.  Just remember that there can be multiple winners for either class judging or our evaluated cars (HPOF & DPC). 

Thanks, that is very helpful.  Now I just need to pick an event to bring it to.  I am outside of Detroit so the closest one is Auburn, however that event is a Grand National so this car would not qualify I believe.  

 

Kevin

[kfle 235]

41 minutes ago, nzcarnerd said:

If it is mostly original, leave it as it is. It is only original once - you can never unrestore a car.

 

I have no plans to restore this car as my intention is to leave it as original as possible.  This car has been well preserved for so many  years, I am going to enjoy it that way. My goal is to get the car out in the public eye more as it has been hidden away for most of its life.  It is also the only 1925 Cole known to exist still.  

[John_S_in_Penna 2,282]

2 hours ago, Phillip Cole said:

... Considering you have a car with such documented provenance,  you should seriously consider restoring it to be class judged. 

 

I'll have to heartily disagree with advice to restore it.

I'm happy to hear that the only known 1925 Cole will

be kept in its current original state.

 

Thank goodness this car was stored until modern times,

when original cars are very much appreciated.

How much better it is to see what the Cole Motor Car Company

made in 1925, and all the details of how they made it, painted it,

and upholstered it--rather than to see how Joe's Restoration Shop

did it in 2019!

[Matt Harwood 7,418]

It would be a crime to restore that car, especially just to win a trophy.

[C Carl 1,512]

Another vote for strict preservation. Just put your efforts and whatever $$$ necessary to keep it up, and also running as close to 100% as possible. How many miles on your beautiful Cole(s)  ?      -     Carl 

[kfle 235]

1 hour ago, Matt Harwood said:

It would be a crime to restore that car, especially just to win a trophy.

I agree with you and as long as I am the caretaker of this car it will not be restored.  To me the car itself is the award and sharing the car and history with others is the fun part of the hobby.

[Joe in Canada 610]

You could always bring it on the AACA National Vintage tour in Kingston Ont. Aug. 4 to Aug. 9. For cars older than 1932 and not that far for you to come. Love to see it there.

[kfle 235]

38 minutes ago, C Carl said:

Another vote for strict preservation. Just put your efforts and whatever $$$ necessary to keep it up, and also running as close to 100% as possible. How many miles on your beautiful Cole(s)  ?      -     Carl 

Spot on Carl.  The car sat for a couple of years with the previous owner so it is in a shop right now having a mechanical go through and a cleaning/preservation of the surfaces.  They found a bent valve in cylinder 8 and the some gaskets needed replacing so a new valve had to be made and the engine is running great now.  When the previous owner got it in 2007, he was big on preservation as well.  He actually took out an electric fuel pump that was put in at some point and put back in the original vacuum system.  He also did some other mechanical conservation to keep it original and running smooth.  One thing he had to do was to fix the speedo unit and cable so the odometer mileage right now is not right, however he did document everything in great detail.  The log he kept is at the shop with the car, but the original miles on the odometer were about 31,000.  

 

My 1923 Cole Coupe is also a Cole family car and was built by JJ Cole for his son and it was the test car for balloon tires as Cole was the first auto company to have balloon tires on a production car.  It also tested other technology as well.  Anyway, that car was kept in the factory building and owned by the family until 1990.  It had 12,121 original miles at the time.  Unfortunately in the late 70's there was a river flood by the factory and the basement partially flooded.  Where the coupe was sitting got a lot of water so the owner that bought it from the Coles had to restore it, but they restored everything over a ten year restoration that was finished in 2008 and it was done the way it was.  The car currently has about 12,500 miles on it as the previous owner did not use it that much at all.  I just acquired this one last October.  

 

The 1913 Cole is fully restored and I bought it that way in April of 2018.   It has good documentation on it as well and has about 45,000 miles on it at this point.  It sat in a museum in Indiana for 12 years until I acquired it.  

 

Kevin

[Terry Bond 845]

Wow, would love to see that car-let us know where you will be taking it. 

I do recommend putting it into the HPOF class.  One thing not mentioned yet is you can also put it in it's proper class along with all the other cars being judged and choose the "do not judge" option for it.   That way you will be parked with similar cars.  I've done that before with my 1914 Model T.  It's an older restoration so has a few nicks and scrapes, but it loves to be parked with the other Model Ts.  Wherever it goes though, I'm sure it will draw a lot of attention. 

Terry

[kfle 235]

4 minutes ago, Joe in Canada said:

You could always bring it on the AACA National Vintage tour in Kingston Ont. Aug. 4 to Aug. 9. For cars older than 1932 and not that far for you to come. Love to see it there.

I will have to look into that.  I have never taken one of these cars across the border.  Are there any considerations with that?

[Matt Harwood 7,418]

4 minutes ago, kfle said:

I will have to look into that.  I have never taken one of these cars across the border.  Are there any considerations with that?

 

No issues as a tourist. Just like any other car. You will need your passport, however.

[Marty Roth 1,509]

I vote for Preservation-

They are only ORIGINAL ONCE,

and yes, please consider driving it on the AACA VINTAGE TOUR in Kingston, Ontario.

We'll be there with our 1930 Packard (or the '15 Hudson?)

[wayne sheldon 425]

My disgustingly bad story here is that not quite thirty years ago I had one of the best unrestored cars I had EVER seen. Sadly, a few years later, financial necessity required me to sell it. Although I sold it to a friend and fellow hobbyist that also appreciated unrestored cars (he and I were both ahead of the curve on liking them kept that way), he also sold the car a couple years after that. About that time, the HPOF classes were getting a foothold and gaining recognition. Unfortunately, a subsequent owner decided to spend  (believe it or not!) over $50,000 to completely restore the car. Made me sick when I heard about it. I got a great deal of personal satisfaction however a few years later when that person tried to sell the car. The car he had paid $20,000 for, and then the $50K on restoration, he could not get a buyer for at $35,000.

 

Your '25 Cole is without a doubt one of a very small number of really original (pre 1930) cars that I have ever seen (even pictures of) that I can truly say is in better condition than the car I had!

I cannot adequately express how fantastic I think that Cole is.

I am pleased that you are its current (and hopefully for a long time to come) caretaker.

[kfle 235]

9 hours ago, Terry Bond said:

Wow, would love to see that car-let us know where you will be taking it. 

I do recommend putting it into the HPOF class.  One thing not mentioned yet is you can also put it in it's proper class along with all the other cars being judged and choose the "do not judge" option for it.   That way you will be parked with similar cars.  I've done that before with my 1914 Model T.  It's an older restoration so has a few nicks and scrapes, but it loves to be parked with the other Model Ts.  Wherever it goes though, I'm sure it will draw a lot of attention. 

Terry

I will let you know when I figure it out.  Good tip on the do not judge and that sounds like a good idea!

[Roger Frazee 178]

Beautiful car, kfle, and it sounds like the car is in good hands.  This car is a living piece of history as it sits.  I would encourage you to enter it as an HPOF vehicle and enjoy being a part of the Auburn meet.  The HPOF area is arguably the most interesting section of the show field.

[kfle 235]

4 hours ago, wayne sheldon said:

My disgustingly bad story here is that not quite thirty years ago I had one of the best unrestored cars I had EVER seen. Sadly, a few years later, financial necessity required me to sell it. Although I sold it to a friend and fellow hobbyist that also appreciated unrestored cars (he and I were both ahead of the curve on liking them kept that way), he also sold the car a couple years after that. About that time, the HPOF classes were getting a foothold and gaining recognition. Unfortunately, a subsequent owner decided to spend  (believe it or not!) over $50,000 to completely restore the car. Made me sick when I heard about it. I got a great deal of personal satisfaction however a few years later when that person tried to sell the car. The car he had paid $20,000 for, and then the $50K on restoration, he could not get a buyer for at $35,000.

 

Your '25 Cole is without a doubt one of a very small number of really original (pre 1930) cars that I have ever seen (even pictures of) that I can truly say is in better condition than the car I had!

I cannot adequately express how fantastic I think that Cole is.

I am pleased that you are its current (and hopefully for a long time to come) caretaker.

 

Wayne,

 

That is a heartbreaking story and I can't imagine how disappointing that must have been.  I had been looking for this car and I was able to track it down and fell in love with it even more when I saw it in person.  I absolutely plan on being the caretaker of this car for a long time and then my son after that.  He is 18 now and has a great love for pre war cars and especially Coles.  It is a great hobby and passion that we can share together.  

 

Here is a Cole family photo from the late 40's of them taking 4 of their Cole cars out for a local trip to a park.   The 1925 Cole is the last one in the photo.  I have been unbelievably fortunate to acquire three of the four cars in the picture.  The 1923 Coupe and 13 Touring car have both been restored by previous owners but were done right and with care.  Unfortunately both of those cars were affected by a flood that got part of the basement.  Luckily the Brouette was not hit by the flood!  Also here is a photo that appeared in the Indy Star paper in the 70's showing the 25 Brouette and a 24 Royal Sedan in the basement of the Cole factory with someone looking under the hood of the Brouette.  

 

Kevin

[Restorer32 1,517]

Even as a restorer I have to encourage you not to restore your Cole. I always caution people though. The phrase "it's only original once" is true but that "once" is the day it left the factory. After that day it may have significant original features but they have deteriorated to a greater or lesser degree from "original". At best you can maintain and preserve the car in the state of deterioration it was in when you received the car. Again, please do not do any major restoration to your Cole.