To reinforce my remarks of somewhat earlier in this string, the owner's manual for my 1925 Rover says:
1. Under normal conditions, provided that the lamps and starter are used a fair amount, the battery should be kept on charge all the time during the winter and about half the day-time running in the summer.
2. Always keep the left-hand switch pointing to 'D' when the head lamps are in use. (That is the charging position; D for dynamo).
3. If the car is used for long tours in the day-time it is quite unnecessary to keep the charging switch 'on' all the time, as this will cause overcharging of the battery and consequent reduction of the acid level.
Ken G, 1925 Rover 16/50 (San Francisco)
I guess England believed in more operator controls than American companies.
My 1930s American car has no operator controls to change the charging rate. And I think that was typical of many/most American cars. You opened the hood and adjusted the location of the third brush on the generator to set the charging to be about right on average. That meant seasonal changes (more lights and a higher starter requirement in winter than in summer, etc.) and for the type of driving the owner typically did. Basically this system was used because it was cheap and almost adequate, not because was technically good. If they were going to add controls to adjust the charging it was just about as easy to put a voltage regulator on the thing. Which they started doing just as soon as the accessory loads (radios, etc.) and increased lighting loads made the third brush systems woefully inadequate.
If your driving pattern is a number of small trips (neighborhood check out drives, etc.) with occasional long tours then you will be forever twiddling with the third brush adjustment. Or you will set it on the high side for the short trips and then run your lights on the tours.
But you can hide a electronic regulator under the cover where the judges can't see it and forget about actually using the third brush. Works for both long and short trips. Summer and winter. Day and night.